MNS Langkawi's Blog

Persatuan Pencinta Alam Malaysia

Keeping tourism in balance with nature

CASE STUDY:
Eifion Rees

5th January, 2010

Irshad Mobarak, a self-taught naturalist and environmentalist from the Malaysian island of Langkawi says that development need not mean destruction

It’s a simple equation: cleared forests equal cleared hotel rooms
Tourism is a double-edged sword in Langkawi. With its turquoise seas and white beaches, 80 per cent of the economy of this Malaysian archipelago of 99 islands is linked to tourism, but overdevelopment and rainforest clearances are threatening the natural attractions that draw people to its shores.

What sets it apart from its rivals in the region – Bali, Phuket and Penang, where the nightlife is glitzier, the beaches more beautiful and the shopping more plentiful – is its geography and biodiversity. Expanses of moss-green rainforest, mangrove swamps, tree-clad limestone mountains, coastal forests, mudflats, marine parks of hard and soft coral, 220 species of birds, many mammals, dolphins, migrating whale sharks and other wildlife.

Intense logging over the years has taken its toll, however, and continues today, despite Langkawi’s forests being protected. With more than half its precious natural heritage lost, the ‘Jewel of Kedah’ (Kedah being the mainland state to which Langkawi belongs) is at a tipping point.

It is something that Irshad Mobarak, a self-taught naturalist who has been working on Langkawi for the past 23 years, is determined to do something about.

Jungle hero

In 1994 he set up JungleWalla, a company offering nature, wildlife and birdwatching tours to visitors, and spends the rest of his time overseeing the many conservation projects he has initiated. He uses the diversity and interdependence of the rainforest as an object lesson in how we ought to see our relationship with nature.

Jobs may matter on the island, but destroying whole ecosystems to make way for new developments or to create farmland is a shortsighted approach. ‘Not to protect Langkawi’s natural capital is economic suicide,’ Irshad says.

A charismatic and well-known character on the island, he won an ‘Amazing Malaysians’ award in 2007 for his environmental work, and is currently galvanising support for the rainforest through a series of talks to hotels and hospitality industry staff, the bedrock of the tourism industry. He aims to collect 4,000 signatures on a petition calling upon Langkawi’s authorities to do more to protect the islands’ natural heritage.

‘Those who are native to the island have most to lose,’ he says. ‘The destruction of their natural heritage not only jeopardises their jobs in the tourism industry, but also will impact on the farming and fishing industries, and ultimately on their quality of life.’

An education

The focus is on educating as many islanders as possible, with the petition demanding that all remaining wildlands be totally protected from development and illegal encroachment, for the sake of the island’s water security, to mitigate climate change, flash floods and water pollution into rivers and seas, and for the sake of the island’s ecotourism industry.

Environmental activism is not commonplace on Langkawi, however, and the authorities on the whole seem wary of Irshad’s approach. Small wonder, when some are part of the problem. On a national level, Malaysia has severe problems with logging, and Irshad says on Langkawi it is an open secret that much encroachment into forested areas is indirectly supported by local political figures. Logging teams start deep within the jungle and cut their way out; vast swathes are cleared before anyone notices what is happening.

In a recent town hall meeting in Kuah, Langkawi’s main town, in front of more than 300 people, Langkawi’s highest-ranking state official, the district officer, spoke out against organised illegal encroachment and deforestation by groups of as many as 70 people with the quiet backing of local political figures. ‘When the time comes to apply for the legal papers for these newly cleared lands it is not the poor benefiting, but richer individuals who already have land elsewhere,’ says Irshad.

The disconnect between the powers-that-be and the great environmental issues facing Langkawi, and Malaysia as a whole, are exemplified by Kedah’s Menteri Besar (state governor) Azizan Abdul Razak, who said last year that opponents of deforestation shouldn’t ‘be too obsessed with caring for the environment, like parents who are extremely obsessed with their offspring’.

Habitat loss and the island conundrum

Islands are particularly prone to environmental degradation, home to half the 724 known animal extinctions in the past 400 years and 90 per cent of bird extinctions. With a limited geographical range, unique island species are more likely to succumb to disease, fire, bad weather and normal fluctuations in population, all exacerbated by human action.

The warning signs are already there on Langkawi. Illegal encroachment into wild areas to build roads, hotels and other developments is dividing wildlife habitats. As the rainforest dwindles, the land loses the ability to soak up heavy rainfall, making flash floods more common, destroying the island’s pastures and paddy fields.

Run-off from the land spills into the sea, affecting fish stocks already damaged by unsustainable fishing practices. Unsustainable agriculture is adversely affecting biodiversity. Local people torch scrub to clear more land, triggering bush fires in the dry season.

Poaching has decimated populations of species such as the mouse deer, and feral dogs prey on ground-nesting birds. The rainforest is also a vital carbon sink, and with pollution levels increasing in line with development, it is more important than ever it be protected.

Langkawi has 350 species of butterfly, many of which are found nowhere else on the planet, as well as 220 species of bird, including the Wreathed, Pied and iconic Great Hornbill. All are threatened by the loss of habitat on Langkawi: 49 per cent has already been destroyed; the remainder has been heavily fragmented into six smaller and isolated ‘island habitats’ within the archipelago itself.

Valuable assets

‘Langkawi is experiencing an unprecedented level of habitat loss and fragmentation,’ says Irshad. ‘Animals can no longer move safely from one part of their habitat to another to feed, breed or to patrol their territory. This may result in inbreeding and eventually a decrease in the viability of the species’ gene pool, causing extinction. Loss of habitat compounded by habitat fragmentation is the biggest threat to the island’s natural biodiversity. The island is in grave danger of losing its most valuable asset.’

Langkawi markets itself as an ecotourism destination, and Irshad’s message is that development needn’t mean destruction. As well as his campaign of education and petitioning the authorities, he has a wealth of alternative suggestions for how the rainforest can provide for the people [see box below] – none of which involves a chainsaw. Irshad says there is a growing awareness among Langkawians that they have a stake in protecting their ecosystems and biodiversity, and he feels positive about the future.

‘More effort needs to be made, but I am optimistic that we can reach a place where there is equilibrium between the needs of people and the needs of nature.’

On an island in thrall to the tourist dollar, the appeal to the bottom line seems guaranteed to get results – especially given that elections on Langkawi are usually won by slim margins of as little as 600 votes; the recently set-up Langkawi branch of the Malaysian Nature Society, with Irshad as its chair, which will help add more weight to the cause.

It’s a simple equation: cleared forests equal cleared hotel rooms. Halting and reversing this trend on Langkawi would be an important sign that the tourist industry has learned that it depends on its forests, and cannot afford to destroy them.

If Irshad Mobarak’s campaign yields results on Langkawi, it may not be long before his attitude towards environmental protection – infectious and positive; a rare and unique species in itself – breaks out from the islands and begins to repopulate the mainland.

Eifion Rees is a freelance journalist

Precision farming: Irshad Mobarak, naturalist, Langkawi

‘Why remove the rainforest to rear non-indigenous beef cattle when you can farm mouse deer or rusa within a rainforest?’ Irshad asks. ‘The price of venison is two to three times the price of beef, and much healthier. It is a known fact that wild honey is five to 10 times more nutritious than the imported honey made using modern techniques, so why not promote apiculture? To protect his own interests, the villager will become the guardian of the rainforest around him.’

Instead of rainforests being devastated by the monoculture farming practices associated with growing rubber, palm oil, cocoa or livestock, Irshad aims to show that farmers can tap into natural ecosystems to earn a living – what he calls “eco-wisdom” in farming – without having to chop down trees. The rainforest consists of emergents (above 40m), canopy (30m-40m) and understorey (below 30m), each with distinct microclimates and flora.

Irshad is developing an experimental multi-tiered farm he hopes will prove that one hectare of rainforest can make more money than one hectare of monoculture, shifting the cash incentive towards protection instead of destruction. The first phase – farming mushrooms and orchids, both high-value crops – has already proved a success, with a native tree nursery, woodcraft industry from fallen trees and the collection and selling of wild herbs to be trialled next.

Filed under: Education, Habitat Destruction, Invasive Species, Overharvesting, Population Pressure, Uncategorized

Browse by month

Enter your email address to receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 12 other followers

RSS Malaysia Conservation News

  • Water conservation surcharge review between us and SPAN, says PBAPP - Malay Mail Online 2017/08/10
    Malay Mail OnlineWater conservation surcharge review between us and SPAN, says PBAPPMalay Mail OnlinePicture by KE OoiGEORGE TOWN, Aug 10 — The Penang Water Supply Corporation (PBAPP) said it is still awaiting feedback from the National Water Services Commission (SPAN) on a water conservation surcharge (WCS) review. PBAPP chief executive officer ...and more  […]
  • Malaysian lauded as CNN Hero for sun bear conservation effort - New Straits Times Online 2017/07/29
    New Straits Times OnlineMalaysian lauded as CNN Hero for sun bear conservation effortNew Straits Times OnlineKOTA KINABALU: Penang-born wildlife biologist Dr Wong Siew Te is a living proof that the most ordinary of people can make an extraordinary impact. The 48-year-old biologist was featured this week as one of the CNN Heroes for his sun bear conservation  […]
  • Infinity Logistics, firms band together to renew Pulau Indah mangrove - Malay Mail Online 2017/08/19
    Malay Mail OnlineInfinity Logistics, firms band together to renew Pulau Indah mangroveMalay Mail Onlinefile photoKUALA LUMPUR, Aug 19 — Fifteen firms planted nearly 4,000 mangrove trees in Pulau Indah last month as part of the International Day for the Conservation of the Mangrove Ecosystem. The tree-planting campaign was to help restore the area's ... […]
  • Positive turtle conservation efforts - The Star Online 2017/07/31
    The Star OnlinePositive turtle conservation effortsThe Star OnlinePahang Fisheries Department director Datuk Adnan Hussain said that this was from the 15,428 eggs laid by 176 turtles that nested at the conservation centre during the same period. "It takes 60 days for the eggs to hatch, that is why there is a ...and more »
  • Orphaned baby elephants and their plight - Daily Express 2017/08/20
    Orphaned baby elephants and their plightDaily ExpressElephants are a fully protected species under international conservation laws – but this has not stopped appalling acts of violence being committed against trapped elephants. In some cases, the adults are frightened away; in their rush to escape, the ...
  • Royal Belum park roars for 'fading' tigers - The Star Online 2017/07/30
    The Star OnlineRoyal Belum park roars for 'fading' tigersThe Star OnlineIPOH: The Royal Belum State Park in Perak will be designated as a key recovery and conservation area for tigers, which are facing extinction from poaching in the country. WWF Malaysia CEO Datuk Dr Dionysius Sharma said this was a big step towards ...
  • Malaysia's East Coast Rail Link a double-edged sword for environment, wildlife - Mongabay.com 2017/08/09
    Mongabay.comMalaysia's East Coast Rail Link a double-edged sword for environment, wildlifeMongabay.com“It is crucial to take a landscape and ecosystem approach in the planning of such projects, as some areas that are environmentally sensitive or of high conservation value may fall outside of forest reserves,” said Norizan Mohd Mazlan, Head of WWF ...and […]
  • Society calls for conservation of endangered tree species - The Star Online 2017/07/22
    The Star OnlineSociety calls for conservation of endangered tree speciesThe Star OnlineEco-tourism and Conservation Society Malaysia (Ecomy) co-founder and CEO Andrew Sebastian said the species, locally known as balau putih, can only be found at the high conservation value forests (HCVF) of the Sungai Pinang Virgin Jungle Reserve on ...
  • Naturally beautiful - New Straits Times Online 2017/08/17
    New Straits Times OnlineNaturally beautifulNew Straits Times OnlineThis is a seven-day expedition involving 115 researchers from 14 local institutes of higher learning organised by the Ecotourism and Conservation Society of Malaysia (Ecomy ) and supported by Vale Minerals Sdn Bhd. It is the first day of the expedition ...
  • Wild elephant population in peninsula estimated at 1450, says minister - Malay Mail Online 2017/08/12
    Malay Mail OnlineWild elephant population in peninsula estimated at 1450, says ministerMalay Mail OnlineKUALA LUMPUR, Aug 12 — The population of wild elephants in peninsular Malaysia is estimated to be between 1,220 to 1,450, said Natural Resources and Environment Minister Datuk Seri Wan Junaidi Tuanku Jaafar. He said the animal distribution ...and more » […]

Malaysian Nature Society Langkawi

Malaysian Nature Society Langkawi

MNS Manifesto

MNS mission is to promote the study, appreciation, conservation and protection of Malaysia’s natural heritage, focusing on biological diversity and sustainable developments.

MNS Langkawi Committee 2013-2014

Chairman: Mr.Eric Sinnaya
Vice Chairman: Mr.Vijayndran Muniandy
Secretary: Ms.Daisy Samuel
Treasurer: Mr.M.Suresh Kumar Ratnani
Committee Member: Mr Irshad Mobarak, Dato Alexander Issac, Tun Sarimah Mohd Sharif, Mr Leong Ah Min,
Mr Teoh Cheng Kung, Mr Borhan Hamid.

Become A Member!

Write to us at mnslangkawi@gmail.com to join up and become part of a dynamic group of people passionate about the protection of Langkawi Natural Heritage.

Join us on Facebook!

Follow us on our Facebook Group: interact, post your comments and images and be the first to participate in Langkawi conservation campaigns!

Enter your email address to receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 12 other followers